“Hook”-1991
Starring: Dustin Hoffman, Robin Williams
Written By: James V. Hart, Malia Scotch Marmo
Directed By: Steven Spielberg
* * (out of 4)
I’ll say right up front that I’m not such a big fan of the big budget special effects films. I have a tendency to prefer good writing and a good story over how a film looks. In too many cases, all of the care and attention goes into the look of the film, and they forgot to actually make a good movie out of it. Naturally, I want a film to look good, but not at the expense of everything else. I’m not interested in going to see a movie simply for its visuals.
1991’s “Hook” spent a lot of time (and money) on it’s visuals. Unfortunately, the visual look of the film is not a pretty one. You’d think they could have come up with something bright, imaginative and fun. Instead, what we get is a dark, dull world that fails on both counts.
The film is, of course, a re-imagining of the Peter Pan story, though it’s probably more accurate to call it a continuation of the original story, beacause now Peter has left Neverland and grown up, having no memories of his past life. He is now Peter Banning, a corporate lawyer and father of 2, though you would never know it, since he’s so busy with work that when he can’t make it to his son’s baseball game, he sends someone from the office with a video camera. His son obviously (and rightfully) resents him.
Peter is married to Moira, (the granddaughter of Wendy from the Peter Pan stories) and the family makes a trip to England to visit old Granny Wendy(Maggie Smith). While there, Peter’s kids are kidnapped, and a ransom note is left by one Capt. James Hook. (We never see Hook fly, so how got out of Neverland and back is never really explained.) And so, Peter is whisked off to Neverland by Tinkerbell (Julia Roberts), to save his kids, and for a re-match with Hook. But, first he must re-learn what it was like to be Peter Pan, since he’s all grown-up.
And, boy has Neverland gone to hell in a hand-basket without Peter. It is a rather dark, dull place with virtually no color. I have always pictured it to be a bright, colorful place. I think of it as being full of a lot of greens, not only full of life, but full of wonder and imagination. Instead what we get is a world full of browns and reds, and looking quite desolate. A black-and-white edition of the Mary Martin play would have more life and imagination that this film does.
Compare Disney’s animated Neverland with the one presented in this film….
Disney's Neverland
Hook's Neverland
I wonder what Hook and the rest of the pirates have done to the place since Peter left. (I can only assume they’ve killed off Tiger Lily and all the rest of the Indians, since they are never seen nor mentioned in the film.)
Even Tinkerbell is devoid of life and color. Again, compare Disney with this version….
Disney's Tinkerbell
Hook's Tinkerbell
That’s really the problem with the whole film–the Neverland scenes are lifeless and boring. It’s dull to look at and to listen to. Hook’s ship looks like an amusement park ride. (Conversely, the pirate films that actually were based off an amusement park ride have a much richer, more exciting, more imaginative look.) Hook himself is never threatening. Dustin Hoffman, truly one of my favorite actors, is unimpressive. He’s just goofing around with the role, which never gives the sense that they’re ever in any real danger.
The film takes a long time to really get going, which is not good for a family film. It’s a long film to begin with(2 hours, 20 minutes), and when it takes as long as it does to have any adventure or excitement (the little that it does have), the kids will lose interest pretty quickly.
I remember watching this film in the theater when I was 5 years old. It put me to sleep. I might have been just slightly too young for it then, but not by much. I just don’t feel there was much for kids to relate to. There wasn’t in 1991, and there sure isn’t now.